Old Trail Tavern + Steak

We absolutely love this place! My wife and I got the Delmonico ribeye; they were both grilled to a perfect medium like we ordered. I also got the mushrooms and onions on top, which were also amazing! I would also highly recommend the "Creeker" drink; it goes so well with the steaks. I'm hard to impress when it comes to steaks, but this place definitely has impressed me. I'm already looking forward to our next visit.

- Justin Kraszewski -

This place is all about the food, and for us the service was not far behind. Unfortunately we were sat at counter-height tables in the center of the room, making conversation difficult. I am not sure how we could have gotten seating in the other dining area. Still. The food was amazing our server was friendly and attentive. We will be back to try other things on the menu

- Janet Richey -

Old Trail Tavern is one of our favorite spots to eat! The food is always amazing — the ribeye steak and pork chops are our favorite and they are always cooked perfectly every time. You can really tell they put care into every meal. The atmosphere is cozy and welcoming, and the staff is always friendly. If you haven’t been, you’re definitely missing out!

- Stacey Arnold -

Was able to reserve a table, but it has to be at least 90 minutes later. Prime rib special for $29.95 tasted great! I ordered the $28.99 (2) crab cakes meal so we could share as it was a better deal to order the 2nd crab cake rather than order a crab cake as an add-on to the steak dinner. Crab cakes were fresh, but I have had more flavorful ones made from blue crabs. The All You Can Eat king crab legs & shrimp combo with fries was $49.95, and many people there were enjoying them, but I don't eat that much! Separate room can be used for parties. I won a $30 gift certificate from a fundraiser, so that helped cover one meal. Casual atmosphere with a small rustic bar. Sunday only open until 7 pm, but rest of the week, they are open until 9 pm. Single men's and women's bathrooms.

- Shelly Damiano -

Can’t say enough good things about Old Trail. We had an awesome dinner! Everything about our evening was great. Highly recommend the prime rib on Fridays and Saturdays! So worth the 40 minute drive

- Maddy Weiss -

I've never had a bad meal here. Threonine rings are the best around. Steaks are tender, juicy and flavorful. Burgers homemade and meal size. Fresh cut fries aren't to be missed. The fresh squeezed mimosa drink is refill worthy.

- Holly Fultz -

We love taking random drives as a family and saw this place and had to try them out. We were not disappointed! Amazing food and atmosphere. It doesn't look like much on the outside but as soon as you walk in the door they were friendly. When the food came out it looked like something you would get at a fine dining restaurant. Everything was absolutely amazing. We got three different burgers and split them with each other to try them all. The pretzel appetizer was delicious. They were able to make a good long island which is hard to find and their s'mores old fashion was delicious. The service was family friendly and our server Amy made everything feel comfortable and at home. Would highly recommend to anyone who is passing by or lives in the area. Well worth the drive! Can't wait to come back and try out their amazing steaks.

- Laura Shotto -

My husband and I have passed this place many of times and finally had the chance to stop and it did not disappoint. Since owning a smoker (grill), it is hard to find a restaurant that impresses us when it comes to steaks. The flavor was fantastic , no steak sauce needed. I ordered mine medium and my husband ordered his rare and they came out perfect. My husband hasn't stopped talking about it since! The whipped potatoes and rice medley were delicious also. The potatoes had lots of flavor and the texture was light and fluffy. We will definitely be back!

- Megan -